Shipt vs Instacart Side Job Comparison

We may receive compensation from the providers of the services and products featured on this website. Read our Advertising Disclosure.

In the fast-paced realm of online grocery delivery, Shipt and Instacart emerge as two prominent platforms linking clients with personal shoppers. Both services provide a convenient means for individuals to supplement their income as independent workers. Yet, when faced with the decision of selecting between Shipt and Instacart for a side job, which one is the more suitable choice? This in-depth examination will explore the major distinctions, shopper perspectives, and potential earnings of both platforms in order to assist you in determining the optimal option for generating income. This is the Shipt vs Instacart Side Job Comparison.

Overview of Shipt and Instacart

Shipt is an internet-based service that brings groceries directly to customers’ doorsteps in various cities across the United States. Shipt shoppers are in charge of choosing and delivering grocery orders from nearby stores. The platform offers a flexible schedule, allowing shoppers to choose their preferred delivery times.

Meanwhile, Instacart, a more widely recognized service, operates in most zip codes across North America, including the United States and Canada. Instacart has two types of shopper roles: in-store shoppers who prepare orders for pickup and full-service shoppers who both shop for and deliver orders. Like Shipt, Instacart allows its shoppers to create their own delivery schedules.

Earning Potential

One of the first things to consider when choosing between Shipt and Instacart is the earning potential. Both platforms pay their shoppers on a per-order basis, with earnings comprising a base pay and any customer tips.

Shipt: Shipt drivers, or shoppers, can expect to earn an average of $15 to $25 per hour. This amount can vary based on the order size, delivery distance, and the time of day. Shipt also offers promotional pay during peak hours and for larger orders.

Instacart: Instacart shoppers’ earnings vary widely depending on whether they are full-service or in-store shoppers. Full-service shoppers can make between $15 to $20 per hour, while in-store shoppers have a fixed hourly wage that typically starts at minimum wage. Instacart’s payment structure includes a base pay per batch, tips, and peak hour bonuses.

Membership and Service Fees

Both Shipt and Instacart offer membership options that provide benefits such as free delivery and reduced service fees.

Shipt Membership: Shipt offers an annual membership for $99, which includes free delivery on orders over $35. Customers can also opt for a monthly membership at $14. For shoppers, this means more consistent orders from committed members.

Instacart Express Membership: Instacart’s membership, known as Instacart Express, costs $99 annually or $9.99 monthly. It offers free delivery on orders over $35 and reduced service fees. As with Shipt, this can lead to more frequent orders from regular customers.

Shopper Experience and Requirements

The shopper experience and requirements for both platforms have some similarities but also key differences.

Shipt: To become a Shipt shopper, you must be at least 18 years old, have a reliable vehicle (1997 or newer), and pass a background check. Shipt provides a more personal shopping experience, as shoppers often communicate directly with customers via the Shipt app to discuss substitutions and preferences.

Instacart: Instacart requires shoppers to be at least 18 years old, have access to a car (for full-service shoppers), and pass a background check. The Instacart app facilitates communication between shoppers and customers, especially regarding substitution preferences.

Flexibility and Scheduling

Both Shipt and Instacart boast flexible scheduling, but there are some nuances to consider.

Shipt: Shoppers can set their own schedule by claiming delivery windows in advance. This flexibility allows individuals to work around their personal commitments, making it a great side hustle for those with limited free time.

Instacart: Instacart offers similar flexibility, with shoppers able to choose their hours and batch orders. However, the platform operates on a first-come, first-served basis, so securing desirable delivery times may require quick action.

Customer Service and Support

The level of customer service and support can impact the shopper experience on both platforms.

Shipt: Shipt is known for its responsive customer service, with support available through live chat, phone, and email. This can be a huge advantage for shoppers needing assistance during their shopping trips.

Instacart: Instacart also offers customer support through live chat and email. However, some shoppers express concern over longer wait times for assistance compared to Shipt.

Additional Considerations

  • Local Grocery Stores: Both platforms partner with various local and regional retailers, which can affect the availability of orders and the types of products shoppers handle.
  • Delivery Apps Comparison: When comparing Shipt and Instacart to other delivery apps, such as DoorDash or Uber Eats, it’s important to consider the differences in job nature. Grocery delivery involves more personal interaction and attention to detail.
  • Social Media and Reviews: Checking social media and online reviews can provide insight into the experiences of other shoppers on both platforms.
  • Direct Deposit: Both Shipt and Instacart offer direct deposit for earnings, ensuring a convenient way to access your money.

Conclusion: Shipt vs. Instacart – Which is Best for Making Money?

Ultimately, the choice between Shipt and Instacart depends on your personal preferences, availability, and market demand in your metropolitan areas. If you prefer a more personal shopping experience with potentially higher earnings per order, Shipt might be a better fit. On the other hand, if you value a larger customer base and the opportunity to work as an in-store shopper, Instacart could be more suitable. The Shipt vs Instacart Side Job Comparison is a very close comparison.

Both platforms offer a flexible schedule for online grocery shopping and the chance to earn extra money by delivering groceries. By weighing the pros and cons and considering your own needs, you can determine which service aligns best with your goals as a personal shopper and independent contractor in the world of online grocery delivery services.

How to Successfully Budget on a Low Income