TurboTax vs. Tax Preparers: Making the Right Choice

We may receive compensation from the providers of the services and products featured on this website. Read our Advertising Disclosure.

Tax season is a time that many individuals dread, but it’s a necessary part of managing our finances. When it comes to filing your taxes, you have two main options: using tax software or hiring a tax preparer. Both approaches have their pros and cons, and deciding which one is right for you depends on various factors. In this article, we will explore the differences between tax software like TurboTax and tax preparers, the advantages and disadvantages of each option, and provide guidance to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding TurboTax

TurboTax has become increasingly popular in recent years. This type of software is designed to guide you through the tax filing process, helping you accurately complete your return and maximize your deductions. TurboTax, in particular, offers various packages to cater to different tax situations, from simple returns to more complex scenarios involving rental properties or business income.

Get your taxes done here with Turbo Tax

Advantages of Using Turbo Tax

One of the primary advantages of using tax software is the convenience it offers. You can file your taxes from the comfort of your own home, at any time that suits you. The software provides a user-friendly interface that prompts you to enter the necessary information step by step, ensuring that you don’t miss anything important. It also performs calculations automatically, reducing the risk of mathematical errors.

Another benefit of using Turbo Tax is its cost-effectiveness. Many tax software programs offer free editions for individuals with simple tax returns. If your tax situation is more complex, you can choose a paid version that is still typically more affordable than hiring a tax preparer.

Disadvantages of Using Turbo Tax

While tax software has its advantages, there are also some disadvantages to consider. One of the main drawbacks is the potential for errors. Despite the software’s accuracy, mistakes can still occur if you input incorrect information or misunderstand a question. These errors can result in incorrect calculations and potentially lead to issues with your tax return. Additionally, Turbo Tax may not be equipped to handle highly complex tax situations, such as those involving multiple sources of income or intricate deductions.

Another disadvantage is the lack of personalized advice. Tax software provides general guidance based on the information you provide, but it cannot offer tailored advice specific to your unique circumstances. This can be a disadvantage if you have questions or need assistance with more complex tax matters.

Hiring a Tax Preparer

Alternatively, you have the option to hire a tax preparer to handle your taxes. Tax preparers are professionals who specialize in tax law and have the expertise to navigate the complexities of the tax code. They can provide personalized advice, help you maximize your deductions, and ensure that your tax return is accurate and compliant with current tax laws.

Advantages of Hiring a Tax Preparer

One of the key advantages of hiring a tax preparer is the expertise they bring to the table. Tax preparers are well-versed in tax laws and regulations, staying up-to-date with any changes that may impact your return. They can provide valuable insights and strategies to help you minimize your tax liability and identify opportunities for additional deductions or credits.

Another advantage of working with a tax preparer is the peace of mind it provides. Filing taxes can be stressful, especially if you have a complex financial situation. By entrusting your taxes to a professional, you can feel confident that your return is in capable hands. Additionally, if you ever face an audit or need to address any issues with your tax return, a tax preparer can provide support and represent you before the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).

Disadvantages of Hiring a Tax Preparer

The primary disadvantage of hiring a tax preparer is the cost. Tax preparers charge a fee for their services, and the cost can vary depending on factors such as the complexity of your tax return, the region you live in, and the specific services required. Hiring a tax preparer may be more expensive than using Turbo Tax, especially if you have a relatively straightforward tax situation.

Another potential disadvantage is the reliance on another individual to complete your taxes. While tax preparers are professionals, there is still a level of trust involved. You must ensure that you choose a reputable and competent tax preparer who will accurately represent your financial information and file your taxes correctly.

Making the Decision: Turbo Tax or Tax Preparer?

Ultimately, the decision between using tax software or hiring a tax preparer depends on your individual needs and circumstances. To help you make an informed choice, consider the following factors:

Complexity of Your Tax Situation

If your tax situation is relatively simple, with only a few sources of income and standard deductions, Turbo Tax may be a suitable option. However, if you have more complex financial affairs, such as rental properties, self-employment income, or investment gains and losses, it may be beneficial to consult a tax preparer who can navigate these intricacies and ensure accurate calculations.

Confidence and Comfort with Tax Laws

If you have a good understanding of tax laws and feel confident in your ability to accurately complete your tax return, using tax software may be a viable option. However, if you are unfamiliar with tax laws or have encountered issues in the past, seeking the expertise of a tax preparer can provide peace of mind and ensure compliance with the tax code.

Time and Availability

Consider your available time and resources when deciding between tax software and a tax preparer. Using tax software allows you to file your taxes at your own convenience, whereas hiring a tax preparer involves scheduling appointments and potentially waiting for their availability. If you have a busy schedule or prefer a hands-off approach, tax software may be more suitable. However, if you value personalized guidance and expert advice, investing the time to work with a tax preparer can be beneficial.


Compare the cost of tax software and hiring a tax expert. Consider the complexity of your tax situation, the potential for savings or deductions, and the fees associated with each option. While tax software might be more affordable for straightforward returns, the benefits of using a tax preparer may outweigh the additional cost in more complicated circumstances.

Choosing the Right Tax Preparation Method: H&R Block vs. TurboTax

As tax time rolls around, many individuals and small business owners face the daunting task of preparing their own tax returns. With numerous tax preparation methods available, it’s crucial to select the one that ensures the best outcome for your individual tax situation. Two of the most popular options are H&R Block and TurboTax, each offering unique features and guarantees to cater to a wide range of needs.

H&R Block: Personalized Tax Assistance from Professionals

H&R Block is renowned for its team of tax professionals, including certified public accountants and tax attorneys, who provide expert advice and support. Whether you’re an individual filer or a small business owner, H&R Block offers a range of services to help you navigate your tax situation. From free federal return filing to more comprehensive audit support, they ensure that you receive the maximum tax savings and a smaller tax due.

One of the key advantages of H&R Block is the personalized attention you receive. Their tax experts are equipped to handle unique situations, such as dealing with local taxes or navigating complex tax laws. This level of support is particularly beneficial for those who may not feel confident handling their own taxes or who have a more complicated financial situation.

TurboTax: User-Friendly Tax Prep Software with Expert Support

TurboTax, on the other hand, is known for its user-friendly tax prep software, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer to file their own taxes. The software guides users through the tax filing process, ensuring accurate calculations and the best possible outcome for their individual returns. TurboTax offers a range of products, including the TurboTax Live Assisted Basic Offer and the TurboTax Live Full Service File option, which provide access to available experts for additional support.

TurboTax stands out for its guarantees, such as the TurboTax Calculation Error Guarantee, the TurboTax Live Full Service Guarantee, and the Maximum Refund Guarantee. These guarantees offer peace of mind by ensuring that users receive the maximum tax savings and that their returns are accurate. Additionally, TurboTax offers specific features for different types of filers, from the free version for simple returns to more advanced options for those with complex tax situations.

Comparing H&R Block and TurboTax: Key Considerations

When choosing between H&R Block and TurboTax, there are several factors to consider. The final price of the service is an important consideration, as it can vary based on your specific tax situation and the level of support you require. Both H&R Block and TurboTax offer transparent pricing, with additional fees for services like state returns or live chat support. Another factor to consider is the level of assistance you need. If you prefer a more hands-on approach with access to tax professionals, H&R Block may be the better choice. However, if you’re comfortable using software and value the convenience of filing your own returns, TurboTax might be more suitable.

Both H&R Block and TurboTax offer guarantees to ensure customer satisfaction. H&R Block’s audit support guarantee and TurboTax’s Accurate Calculations Guarantee provide reassurance against potential errors or state penalties.  Additionally, both services strive to help you achieve the maximum tax savings, with guarantees like the Maximum Refund Guarantee and the Maximum Tax Savings Guarantee.

Whether you choose H&R Block or TurboTax depends on your individual needs, comfort level with tax laws, and preference for professional assistance or self-filing. Both options offer reliable tax preparation methods, with guarantees and features designed to ensure a smooth and successful tax filing experience. By considering factors such as the final price, level of support, and available guarantees, you can make an informed decision that leads to the best outcome for your tax situation.


In conclusion, navigating the complexities of filing an individual tax return can be a daunting task, but choosing the right tax preparation service can make a significant difference. H&R Block and TurboTax offer a range of options to cater to various needs, whether you’re seeking expert help or prefer a more hands-on approach with tax preparation software. The key is to find a service that aligns with your unique situation, whether it’s managing your tax bill, maximizing your tax refund, or ensuring accuracy in your tax forms.

For those seeking personalized assistance, H&R Block provides access to tax professionals who can offer legal advice and support tailored to your actual tax situation. On the other hand, TurboTax Online offers a convenient online platform with features like the applicable TurboTax Live Full Service for those who prefer to take charge of their own returns. Both services offer guarantees to ensure accuracy and satisfaction, from the standard deduction to more complex tax deductions.

As you consider your options, keep in mind factors like the base price, additional terms, and the state purchase price, as well as the availability of support, such as audit letters and answer support. Whether you’re a free edition customer or looking for more comprehensive services, understanding the terms of service, mobile pricing, and the tax preparation features offered by each provider is crucial.

Ultimately, the goal is to ensure a smooth and successful tax filing experience, minimize your tax bill, and maximize your refund. By carefully evaluating your options and utilizing the resources available from H&R Block and TurboTax, you can confidently navigate the tax year and make informed decisions that best suit your financial situation

How to Successfully Save on a Low Budget